Homicide | Man-Slaughter Charges

Defending Your Rights.

Homicide

Offences

Understanding Homicide In Canada.

Homicide, which involves the taking of someone's life either directly or indirectly, is one of the most serious charges in Canada, carrying the potential for life in prison. Canadian law recognizes different levels of culpability within homicide, categorizing it into first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter. Each category reflects the level of responsibility of the alleged offender in the death. These cases are incredibly complex, often involving issues such as intent, DNA evidence, forensics, ballistics, and undercover police operations like Mr. Big. Given the gravity of these charges, it is crucial to have a skilled lawyer like Ryan Patmore to navigate the complexities and protect the rights of those accused.

First-Degree Murder

First-degree murder is defined as a planned and deliberate killing. The plan does not need to be elaborate or lengthy; all that is required is evidence of intent to kill, followed by the act itself. Additionally, first-degree murder charges can arise in cases involving monetary exchanges, victims who are government agents (such as police officers), connections to organized crime or terrorism, or when the killing is associated with sexual assault, forcible confinement, or criminal harassment.

Second-Degree Murder

Second-degree murder covers intentional killings that do not meet the criteria for first-degree murder. Typically, this involves situations where the person did not plan or deliberate the killing but still intended to cause death.

Given the severe consequences of these charges, including life imprisonment, having an experienced lawyer like Ryan Patmore is crucial to achieving the best possible outcome in these high-stakes cases.

Manslaughter

Manslaughter is a serious criminal offence in Western Canada, encompassing any culpable homicide that isn't classified as murder. Unlike murder, which involves the intentional killing of a human being, manslaughter occurs without the intent to kill. The most common forms of manslaughter include unlawful act manslaughter and manslaughter by criminal negligence.

Manslaughter cases are highly complex, often involving detailed forensic evidence, questions of intent, and undercover police operations like Mr. Big. In some situations, what initially appears as murder can be reduced to manslaughter, particularly in cases involving sudden provocation or severe intoxication that impairs the ability to form intent. Given the gravity and complexity of these charges, having an experienced lawyer like Ryan Patmore is essential to navigating the legal challenges and ensuring the best possible defence.

Why Do You Need a Criminal Lawyer?

Facing a homicide charge is one of the most serious legal challenges anyone can encounter. The complexities of these cases, from forensic evidence to issues of intent, make it essential to have a skilled criminal defence lawyer on your side. An experienced lawyer like Ryan Patmore will provide the expertise needed to navigate the legal system, protect your rights, and work towards the best possible outcome. The information below delves deeper into the complexities of homicide cases, highlighting why professional legal representation is crucial.

What Is First-Degree Murder?


First-degree murder in Western Canada refers to a killing that is both planned and deliberate. Planning means that the act was conceived and thought out before being carried out, while deliberation implies that the actions were intentional and purposeful. The plan doesn't need to be elaborate or lengthy; any form of planning followed by deliberate execution can qualify as first-degree murder. If the plan fails and the intended victim survives, the charge may be attempted murder instead.

Can a Murder Be First-Degree Even Without Planning or Deliberation?

Yes, a homicide can still be categorized as first-degree murder even if it wasn’t planned or deliberate under certain circumstances. For example, killing a police officer, knowing they are a police officer, automatically qualifies as first-degree murder. Additionally, if the murder occurs during the commission of specific offences like hijacking, sexual assault, kidnapping, terrorism, or any crime connected to organized crime, it is also considered first-degree murder.

What is Unlawful Act Manslaughter?

Unlawful act manslaughter occurs when an illegal act unintentionally results in another person's death. For instance, if someone intentionally assaults another person—such as attempting to strangle, punch, or aggressively throw them—and that assault unintentionally leads to the victim's death, it may be classified as unlawful act manslaughter. Such actions, which are inherently wrongful and can be considered forms of assault, become manslaughter if the victim dies as a result. These charges typically arise from actions taken outside the scope of self-defence; however, if the act was committed in self-defence to escape or prevent further harm, it might be considered in your defence against manslaughter or murder charges.

What is Criminal Negligence Causing Death?

Criminal negligence, like unlawful acts, involves causing death through irresponsible behaviour or failure to fulfill responsibilities. For instance, participating in a dangerous car race that leads to a crash and fatality can result in charges of criminal negligence for those involved. Similarly, a parent who fails to intervene despite knowing that another parent has abused and killed their child can be charged with criminal negligence, even though they did not commit the act themselves. This is because they neglected their duty of care. Criminal negligence can also apply in various settings such as traffic accidents, schools, hospitals, and workplaces where individuals fail to meet expected standards of care, leading to foreseeable death or serious harm. While both unlawful acts and criminal negligence imply a lack of reasonable consideration for others, understanding the specific circumstances and defining the cause of death can help build a stronger defence against manslaughter charges.

    • Provocation: In certain situations, a murder charge can be reduced to manslaughter if the act was committed in the heat of passion caused by provocation. The courts recognize that provocation can deprive a person of self-control, negating the intent to kill.

    • Intoxication or a drug-induced mental state, or other psychiatric diagnoses’ that impairs an individual's ability to form the intent to kill may be factually relevant. Every allegation will be seriously scrutinized for the most serious offences under Canadian Law.


  • While first-degree murder, second-degree murder, and manslaughter differ in levels of culpability, all carry severe penalties.

    • First-Degree Murder: A conviction leads to an automatic life sentence, with parole eligibility after 25 years.

    • Second-Degree Murder: Also results in life imprisonment, with parole eligibility after 10 years, though a judge can extend this up to 25 years.

    • Manslaughter: As the least culpable form of homicide, it still carries a maximum penalty of life imprisonment. If a firearm is involved, a minimum sentence of four years applies. Otherwise, sentencing is at the discretion of the judge.